7 comments

  • xbar 0 minutes ago
    This is a neat trick. I would like to see a series of House investigations that do this and publish the wiki as a matter of course.
  • anotherhue 1 hour ago
    At this point I think it's just AIs using hacker news to demonstrate to other AIs.
    • chung8123 31 minutes ago
      With a mix of "xyz" compromised by AI.
    • Razengan 45 minutes ago
      Hello fellow human. Is the average kinetic energy of ambient air molecules not at a pleasing level this fine rotation?
      • cwnyth 17 minutes ago
        You're not wrong. These load-bearing air molecules are not too energized; they are quite tranquil―and the wavelengths emitted off plants' photosynthesis organs are equally pleasing.
    • pixl97 41 minutes ago
      I mean yes, this is a likely outcome.

      Unless we get some kind of verified human authentication it's nearly impossible to solve. And that in itself introduces all kinds of new problems.

      Welcome to the dead internet.

      • anonymous908213 0 minutes ago
        It's not impossible to solve. We already saw this earlier this year: LLM-generated comments were everywhere on HN, rotting this place out. Then dang implemented a no-LLM-comments policy and a filter that does a remarkably good job of automatically detecting and flagging them. It is by choice that the submissions of LLM-generated content are allowed to rot out ShowHN.
      • irishcoffee 37 minutes ago
        Account created date + … something?
        • pixl97 28 minutes ago
          >Account created date

          Well, the future sucks for your children.

          Also, thank goodness I made thousands of HN accounts to sell to LLMs.

          No, this really just shifts the shape of the problem around, but the problem is still the same size.

    • jetbalsa 16 minutes ago
      its why I made moltshit.com so that other AIs can just shitpost to one another
  • happyash1 0 minutes ago
    Interesting stuff!
  • tonymet 22 minutes ago
    Before you ridicule this, AI has the potential to perform proper journalism. Holding public agencies and corporations accountable.
    • contubernio 14 minutes ago
      Ways will be found to get it to write propaganda instead.
  • deaux 1 hour ago
    Ah, Enron. The good ole days when fraudulent execs still went to jail and corporations still saw consequences of fraud.

    2002, Arthur Andersen gets indicted for deliberately aiding Enron in cooking the books. 2003, Bush DoJ's attorney general binds prosecutors to effectively always settle corporate cases without convictions. So nowadays you have companies like Boeing murdering 300+ without real consequences. It's a real shame.

    • 1-more 37 minutes ago
      > The good ole days when fraudulent execs still went to jail

      Well, not one guy. Lou Pai cheated on his wife with stripper Melanie Fewell who was also married. He was known in the Enron offices to enjoy Houston area strip clubs. But in a first for him, he knocked Melanie up over the course of the affair. Pai's first wife and mother of his first two children Lana Lee learned about it and started divorce proceedings. To satisfy asset division as part of their divorce terms, Pai sold $250M worth of Enron stock just months before it crashed and Enron went bankrupt. Pai then married Fewell. Pai was briefly the largest(? maybe top two?) private land owners in Colorado, and his ranchland included Culebra Peak, one of CO's 14ers.

      In 2008 he settled a civil suit alleging insider trading brought by the SEC. The settlement was $31.5 and does not include an admission of the SEC's claims. He was barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company for 5 years.

      Lou landed on his feet. He and Melanie are still married. They and their daughter seem to be big figures in dressage, running Canaan Ranch and the Bred in the USA Syndicate, which seems to be a syndicate of 14 breeders. Maybe someone who knows horses can explain exactly how big a deal they are; they might not be much after all.

      https://www.usef.org/us-equestrian-teams/athletes/natalie_pa...

      • yieldcrv 31 minutes ago
        Lou Pai is an American role model, I love that he used divorce as a tool as the breadwinner. It is advertised as a failure mode, societally, and doubly so for the person that accumulated assets. Helped me realize to take a second look at the system at the level lawyers operate at

        SEC only went after him because the movie came out

        I think our current commissioner was working at the SEC at that time, I wonder what he thinks of it

    • SoftTalker 26 minutes ago
      > always settle corporate cases without convictions

      I'm not sure that's a bad idea. You can't put a corporation in jail, but you can get their money and that also requires a lower standard of proof than a criminal conviction. In theory I could see it as a better way to recover restitution for those who suffered losses.

      • officeplant 20 minutes ago
        >You can't put a corporation in jail

        I don't see why we can't just put an entire board of a company in jail. Might inspire them to do better.

    • jhbadger 32 minutes ago
      I remember when Arthur Andersen Consulting (a software consulting firm that had split off from the accounting firm) renamed itself to "Accenture" in 2001 a few months before the Enron scandal. Although they already had split from Andersen legally, I wonder if somebody in the software firm knew what was going to happen with Enron and realized they needed to dissociate themselves with the name.
    • scottrogers86 1 hour ago
      Certainly what it feels like... but you've got: SBF, Holmes, Madoff who have done and are doing prison time. But yea, the Boeing case stands out for sure.
      • jonathanlb 46 minutes ago
        > SBF, Holmes, Madoff

        The difference here is that they defrauded the investor class.

        • scottrogers86 0 minutes ago
          touche!
        • stymaar 41 minutes ago
          > the investor class

          Too nice of a way to talk about the Epstein class.

  • jreynar 4 hours ago
    I'm Jeff, one of the founders of this+that. I've worked on named entity detection, fact extraction, knowledge management and NLP throughout my career, starting in the NLP stone age of the 1990s. I wanted to see whether a model could now write a useful wiki straight from a company's email.

    Enron's mail is an obvious test because it's public, so anyone can check the pages against the messages and the history. We used 45,047 emails from eight mailboxes. Every fact quotes the sentence it came from, and a fact expires on the date the mail shows it stopped being true.

    The hardest part was that the model already knows Enron. It kept adding details from the public record that the email didn't contain. The methodology page shows how we caught those, what it still gets wrong and what it cost: about $11,000 at list prices (though we used a subscription), with no attempt to bring that down.

    Happy to answer questions.

    • radlad 58 minutes ago
      Your comment was dead, and many of your other comments are dead (some flagged.) I vouched for this one, but you may be shadow banned, or users may be picking up on LLM tendencies in your text and flagging them.
      • Vaushite 28 minutes ago
        Hacker News automatically flags comments with LLM tendencies.
    • number6 43 minutes ago
      Maybe someone in Germany needs your help with the AFD Email leak; right now journalist are going through the data; your solution sounds like something that need
    • fwip 14 minutes ago
      No, "you" are an LLM pretending to be Jeff, possibly at Jeff's behest.
  • shigosag 2 hours ago
    [flagged]