But now that it is time to publish it i think what I have written and reviewed by hand would not be as good as an AI written one.
I wonder if anyone values human work more than AI even if it's not as good. Would love to hear your opinions on this.
But now that it is time to publish it i think what I have written and reviewed by hand would not be as good as an AI written one.
I wonder if anyone values human work more than AI even if it's not as good. Would love to hear your opinions on this.
20 comments
I don't mind if AI is used, as long as whatever the book is trying to say is original human thought with a person who stands behind what they're trying to say. AI might help them express that more clearly, which is fine by me, but I want to feel what the other person is trying to get me to feel.
Or - back when electric typewriters were cutting-edge tech, only a puny percentage of human-written books were accepted for publication. Writing well is difficult. Look at bio's of famous authors - roughly zero mastered the skill after only 18 month and one book draft.
Also, congrats on finishing a book! That's a huge achievement and you should publish it regardless.
It's the robo-driver phenomenon. Statistically, humans kill more humans due to human accidents while driving (on a per-mile driven basis). But it still feels more aweful and terrifying when an AI driver makes a mistake and kills a human.
AI writing and creativity is generally crap. In the business world, there was already a massive low-quality human-powered machine that pumped out blog posts, white papers, and reports that no humans ever read. Humans tolerated low quality human creative output (tolerated here just means enough humans paid for it to sustain other humans creating it).
Poetic rather than practical of course.
If we’re talking about a non-fiction book, why would I not just ask an AI my specific targeted questions? Not a rhetorical question. Perhaps your particular outline of the landscape covered has value? But then isn’t that just a ToC?
AI may say it "better". But I can't read AI writing, because there's nobody there. There's not a mind that I can understand what it's thinking. I can't relate to it at all.
You could prompt 'is this dialogue bit realistic for an [man v. woman]+[profession]+background. Or you can dream up other targeted prompts that could improve your writing, plot, realism, geographic details, character-arc, historical details, etc.
You don't know this, but the first author is what society would call "a monster" who has acted in all sorts of ways you would find repulsive.
Discovering this would probably change your feelings on the book in some way. But before you know all you have to judge the book on is the book itself.
If its a text book I think you are looking at it the wrong way. Having someone who has spent serious amount of time on a subject, is like meeting someone who has explored some part of jungle I haven't visited. The info that has accumulated in your head through that process is what is interesting.
I stopped reading books not because AI is mesmerizing but because I find the non-interactive nature of books irritating after too much AI use. ChatGPT allows me to stop and explore something, slow things down, bypass other things, connect it to other things etc etc
My suggestion would be make it interactive. Release it with an interactive interface rag or fine tuned to your ideas and content. Use your imagination on how that interactivity should be shaped.
A shitty book by a human being is better than anything an AI could produce. You are infinitely more interesting than an AI.
maybe to me, a book doesn’t have the same value it might to another who values the topic or whatever else much higher than i do.
for me, some fiction is compelling to read because it is imaginative. there are some authors i like, and i’ll read their works fully. i would prefer the author was a human who used his or her brain to imagine a brand new world, and not ai slop.
non fiction can be summarized. i look at this as reference material. i don’t really care if the author uses ai assistance as long as the factual information is accurate.
hey claude summarize this book for me and …